Two California high school football powers. One epic finish.
Mater Dei was trailing St. John Bosco by two touchdowns in the final four minutes, and with a freshman quarterback under center, it wasn’t looking good.
But the Monarchs scored two touchdowns in the final 3:26, then converted a two-point attempt with 7.5 seconds remaining to stun St. John Bosco, 36-35, in a wild Trinity League showdown Friday night at Santa Ana Stadium.
It was a comeback for the ages — and another chapter in one of Southern California high school football’s biggest rivalries.
St. John Bosco appeared to have control after Maliq Allen scored on a 4-yard touchdown run with 4:35 remaining, giving the Braves a 35-21 advantage.
Mater Dei had managed just 37 yards on 15 plays in the second half to that point.
Then freshman quarterback Paytyn Guess found Gavin Honore for a 55-yard touchdown strike with 3:26 left. The score cut the deficit to 35-28 and gave the Monarchs a chance.
Their defense delivered, forcing a St. John Bosco punt and giving the offense one final opportunity.
Mater Dei took over at its own 28-yard line with 55 seconds remaining and no timeouts.
Guess immediately connected with fellow freshman Tristan Brown for a 49-yard completion to move the Monarchs into scoring position. Five plays later, Guess delivered a 12-yard touchdown pass to Brown, who hauled in the ball in the end zone to make it 35-34 with just 7.5 seconds left.
Mater Dei had a decision to make.
Head coach Raul Lara called timeout, and the Monarchs elected to go for two points and the win rather than kick for overtime.
Guess found sophomore tight end Tyler Fritz on a wheel route. Fritz bobbled the ball before securing the juggling catch, sending the Mater Dei sideline into a frenzy.
It was Fritz’s only catch of the night — and it couldn’t have come at a better time.
The Braves managed one final offensive play, but a series of laterals ended with a tackle near midfield. Mater Dei had completed the comeback.
Paytyn Guess Delivers in the Biggest Moment
Guess finished with 214 passing yards and five total touchdowns, accounting for three scores through the air and two on the ground, according to MaxPreps.
The freshman completed 11 of 15 passes and showed poise throughout the final minutes, leading the Monarchs on two touchdown drives when the game was slipping away.
Brown finished with four catches for 104 yards and a touchdown. Honore added five receptions for 97 yards and two touchdowns.
St. John Bosco had its share of offensive fireworks, too.
Junior quarterback Koa Malau’ulu completed 26 of 35 passes for 365 yards and three touchdowns. He also rushed for a score, accounting for four touchdowns in the loss.
Kuika Moaalii led the Braves with seven catches for 128 yards and a touchdown. Jacob Reid added four receptions for 76 yards, while Allen finished with 84 rushing yards on 18 carries and a touchdown.
St. John Bosco actually outgained Mater Dei, 490-315, and held advantages in both passing and rushing yards. It didn’t matter on the scoreboard.
The Monarchs also made an impact on the game’s opening possession. A forced fumble by Montana Toilolo gave Mater Dei an early opportunity, and Guess helped turn it into points inside the opening minute.
Mater Dei Takes Second Place in Trinity League
The victory gives Mater Dei an 8-2 overall record and a 4-1 mark in Trinity League play. The Monarchs finish second in the league behind Santa Margarita, which clinched the outright championship with a win over Orange Lutheran.
St. John Bosco closes the regular season at 7-3 overall and 3-2 in league play.
The Braves entered the season as the nation’s No. 1-ranked team, according to MaxPreps, but Friday’s loss marked their fifth consecutive defeat against Mater Dei.
The Monarchs have now beaten Bosco in each of the past five meetings, including last year’s 36-31 victory and back-to-back CIF Southern Section Division 1 championship games in 2023 and 2024.
Friday’s finish added another memorable moment to the rivalry.
Mater Dei entered the fourth quarter staring at a two-touchdown deficit. It left Santa Ana Stadium with a one-point victory, a second-place Trinity League finish and plenty of momentum heading into the postseason.



GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings